Skip to content
Back to the blog

From my kitchen

Would you bake with everything in a supermarket cake?

If you took the ingredients on a supermarket cake packet shopping, what would you come home with? Here’s how the list compares with the one for my chocolate sponge.

2 min read

Eggs, flour, sugar, butter, cocoa, walnuts and lemon on a baking counter beside a whisk.

Imagine taking the ingredient label from a little supermarket layer cake and using it as your shopping list. The roasted hazelnuts sound lovely. You could pick up the cocoa and a bottle of kirsch on the way home. You’d also need two kinds of milk powder, one whole and one skimmed. And when you reached the oils, a single bottle wouldn’t get you very far.

On this particular cake, sold here in Switzerland, palm oil and palm-kernel oil both appear before the cocoa. Further down there’s palm stearin, the firmer part of palm oil. Both oils are rich in saturated fat. The whole cake weighs just 140 g. The packet counts it as one portion, and if you eat it with your coffee, you’ve had 17 g of saturated fat. That’s 85% of the adult daily reference amount shown on the label. If this is the sort of thing you regularly pick up for an afternoon break, that’s a good reason to reconsider.

When I make chocolate buttercream, I get an emulsifier just by cracking an egg. There’s lecithin in the yolk, and it helps the butter and syrup come together into a smooth filling. The supermarket cake lists five additives for that job alone, with soya lecithin named alongside them.

For the chocolate sponge I bake in Adliswil, I separate five eggs, beat the yolks with sugar and a little grated lemon zest, then whisk the whites until they’re glossy. Once the two are together, I fold in the flour and finely ground walnuts, taking care to keep the air I’ve just beaten into the eggs. The cocoa goes in warm, stirred smooth with butter and a splash of water. That gives me a sponge light enough to cut into three layers, with walnuts and cocoa in every one. I don’t add artificial flavourings.

That’s why I disagree when I hear that you might as well pick up a cake from the supermarket. If you asked me what to buy to make my chocolate sponge this weekend, you could come home with eggs, sugar, flour, butter, cocoa, walnuts and a lemon, turn on the tap, and start baking. Try the same exercise with the cake on the shelf. Would you choose everything you were about to serve?

Bring your own story to the cake table.

Tell me about the occasion, the flavours you love and the people you would like to celebrate.

Tell me which cake you’d like